CryptoMediaClub
Tuesday, November 17, 2026
  • All news
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Altcoins
  • NFT
  • Blockchain
  • Analysis
No Result
View All Result
  • All news
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Altcoins
  • NFT
  • Blockchain
  • Analysis
No Result
View All Result
CryptoMediaClub
No Result
View All Result
Home All news

Appeals Court Raises Doubts About Hermès’ Victory in MetaBirkin NFT Lawsuit

24.10.2024
A A
0
122
VIEWS
ShareShare

A US appeals court judge on Wednesday questioned Hermès’ trial win against an artist accused of infringing on their rights by making NFT versions of their famous Birkin bags.

At a session in the 2nd US Circuit Court of Appeals, Senior US Circuit Judge Pierre Leval suggested that the district judge may have missteered the jury before they decided that Mason Rothschild’s “MetaBirkins” NFTs violated Hermès’ trademarks, Reuters reported.

Leval, one of the three judges hearing the appeal, raised certain concerns. He reportedly questioned whether maintaining Hermès’ victory could restrict artists from using well-known brands in their work. The judge compared this to Andy Warhol’s use of Campbell’s Soup in his art.

Further, he asked Hermès’ attorney if this case could potentially prevent artists from making works intended to critique prominent commercial brands.

Further, he raised concerns about Judge Jed Rakoff’s guidance to the jury, which led to a permanent injunction against Rothschild’s NFT sales for Hermès, questioning whether Rothschild’s intent to deceive consumers truly matched the relevant legal criteria.

Hermès NFT Trial Sparks Debate on Trademark vs. Artistic Expression

Reuters reported that the appeals court wrestled with how to balance trademark rights and First Amendment protections, especially after a Supreme Court ruling in favor of Jack Daniel’s over a company making dog toys shaped like whiskey bottles.

Meanwhile, Circuit Judge Denny Chin questioned Rothschild’s lawyer, asking whether the artist exploited Hermès’s brand to profit from its reputation. He compared this to a recent case where the 2nd Circuit ruled in favor of Vans against artists selling modified shoe designs.

Rothschild Faces Court Defeat in Hermès NFT Case, Appeals on Free Speech Grounds

In Jan. 2022, Hermès sued Rothschild for creating and selling NFTs called “MetaBirkins,” which closely resembled their iconic Birkin handbag, named after Jane Birkin.

Hermès claimed that Rothschild’s NFTs could weaken the Birkin brand’s distinct identity, potentially harming its reputation. The company also accused him of cybersquatting for registering domains like metabirkins.com to profit from Hermès’s brand.

This was the first NFT trademark dispute to go to trial, with a New York jury ruling against Rothschild for trademark infringement, dilution and cybersquatting.

Rothschild appealed to the 2nd US Circuit Court, arguing that his MetaBirkins were an artistic critique of luxury and consumerism, protected under the First Amendment.

The post Appeals Court Raises Doubts About Hermès’ Victory in MetaBirkin NFT Lawsuit appeared first on Cryptonews.

Share9Tweet6ShareSharePin2

Related Posts

Anthropic Claude AI Predicts a Historic BTC Price Reversal
All news

Anthropic Claude AI Predicts a Historic BTC Price Reversal

16.11.2026
0

Bitcoin (BTC) is trading near $64,000–$65,000 in mid-November 2026 after a sharp, multi-week decline that has erased much of its...

Read moreDetails
XRP Price Prediction: Bears Are Paying to Short XRP, A Short Squeeze?

XRP Price Prediction: Bears Are Paying to Short XRP, A Short Squeeze?

16.11.2026
Move Over World of Warcraft: Cardano Has Its Own MMORPG

Move Over World of Warcraft: Cardano Has Its Own MMORPG

16.11.2026
Lighter Halts Crypto Withdrawals After $15.5M Security Breach as LIT Falls

Lighter Halts Crypto Withdrawals After $15.5M Security Breach as LIT Falls

16.11.2026
CZ Fires Back at Binance Dump Claims as Vitalik Bullish on Ethereum Quantum Upgrade

CZ Fires Back at Binance Dump Claims as Vitalik Bullish on Ethereum Quantum Upgrade

16.11.2026
Load More
Next Post
Zanzibar Launches Blockchain Sandbox to Support Tech Startups

Zanzibar Launches Blockchain Sandbox to Support Tech Startups

0 0 votes
Рейтинг статьи
Subscribe
Notify of
guest
guest
0 комментариев
Oldest
Newest Most Voted
Inline Feedbacks
View all comments

Recommended

CCIP Simplified Settlement of Tokenized Assets in Australia

CCIP Simplified Settlement of Tokenized Assets in Australia

3 years ago
Stablecoin Issuer Tether Allocates 15% Profit Every Month To Buy Bitcoin

Stablecoin Issuer Tether Allocates 15% Profit Every Month To Buy Bitcoin

4 years ago
BAYC and Pudgy Penguins Launch on TON, Making it the #1 NFT Blockchain – Is $5 Toncoin Coming?

BAYC and Pudgy Penguins Launch on TON, Making it the #1 NFT Blockchain – Is $5 Toncoin Coming?

1 year ago
Why is the Hunter Biden LAPTOP Launch Facing Backlash from Investors?

Why is the Hunter Biden LAPTOP Launch Facing Backlash from Investors?

2 months ago

Categories

  • All news
  • Altcoins
  • Analysis
  • Bitcoin
  • Blockchain
  • Ethereum
  • NFT
No Result
View All Result

Highlights

XRP Price Prediction: Bears Are Paying to Short XRP, A Short Squeeze?

Michael Saylor says banks could ignite Bitcoin’s next rally as Strategy eyes $48 billion credit expansion

Move Over World of Warcraft: Cardano Has Its Own MMORPG

Japan’s economy stalls, giving Bitcoin no automatic relief from yen funding costs

Lighter Halts Crypto Withdrawals After $15.5M Security Breach as LIT Falls

Solana’s stablecoin market shrinks $919 million as USDC grows

Trending

Bitcoin flashes false recovery warning as $64 billion futures frenzy masks weak demand
Analysis

Bitcoin flashes false recovery warning as $64 billion futures frenzy masks weak demand

16.11.2026
0

The Friday-to-Monday decline establishes fewer open contracts in one segment, while sustained buying would strengthen the case...

Anthropic Claude AI Predicts a Historic BTC Price Reversal

Anthropic Claude AI Predicts a Historic BTC Price Reversal

16.11.2026
Trezor patches crypto wallet spy chips but warns users a new device may not be enough

Trezor patches crypto wallet spy chips but warns users a new device may not be enough

16.11.2026
XRP Price Prediction: Bears Are Paying to Short XRP, A Short Squeeze?

XRP Price Prediction: Bears Are Paying to Short XRP, A Short Squeeze?

16.11.2026
Michael Saylor says banks could ignite Bitcoin’s next rally as Strategy eyes $48 billion credit expansion

Michael Saylor says banks could ignite Bitcoin’s next rally as Strategy eyes $48 billion credit expansion

16.11.2026
  • All news
  • Altcoins
  • Bitcoin
  • Blockchain
  • Ethereum
  • NFT
  • Analysis
Editor: cryptomediaclub.com@gmail.com
Advertising: digestmediaholding@gmail.com

Disclaimer: Information found on CryptoMediaClub is those of writers quoted. It does not represent the opinions of CryptoMediaClub on whether to sell, buy or hold any investments. You are advised to conduct your own research before making any investment decisions. Use provided information at your own risk.
CryptoMediaClub covers fintech, blockchain and Bitcoin bringing you the latest crypto news and analyses on the future of money.

© 2023 Crypto News. All Rights Reserved

No Result
View All Result
  • All news
  • Bitcoin
  • Ethereum
  • Altcoins
  • NFT
  • Blockchain
  • Analysis

Disclaimer: Information found on CryptoMediaClub is those of writers quoted. It does not represent the opinions of CryptoMediaClub on whether to sell, buy or hold any investments. You are advised to conduct your own research before making any investment decisions. Use provided information at your own risk.
CryptoMediaClub covers fintech, blockchain and Bitcoin bringing you the latest crypto news and analyses on the future of money.

© 2023 Crypto News. All Rights Reserved

wpDiscuz